Board approves income tax cut upon levy renewal

The Cloverleaf Board of Education unanimously approved a 0.25 percent reduction in the district’s earned income tax if voters renew a 4.2-mill operating levy on the Nov. 8 ballot. The board voted to approve the measure at its regular meeting Sept. 21.

“Not only has Cloverleaf kept its promise to hold the line on new levies, the Board of Education has taken action to reduce some of the levies we have on the books – and will look at doing so again in the future,” said Board President Jason Myers.

In 2020, when voters approved renewal of the district’s 2-mill Permanent Improvement levy, the board followed through on its promise to reduce the levy’s collection to 1.39 mills. Now, the board is turning its attention to residents who pay the district’s 1.25 percent earned income tax, promising to reduce its collection to 1 percent, if voters renew the operating levy on the ballot in November. The earned income tax cut would take effect Jan. 1.

The district’s ability to offer this potential tax reduction stems from the fact Cloverleaf has reached the minimum level of effective millage allowed by Ohio’s system of school funding – known as the “20-mill floor.” Ordinarily, schools do not receive additional revenue as property values rise. However, when a district reaches the 20-mill floor, non-fixed-dollar levies generate additional funding based on property values to prevent the district from falling below the 20-mill minimum. Effectively, Cloverleaf is promising to give a portion of that revenue back to constituents in the form of a tax reduction.

Additional tax reduction comes from the fact that the cost to taxpayers of the Nov. 8 renewal decreases over time. Originally approved at 6 mills in 2005, it’s collecting at 4.2 mills in 2022, and will be reduced again to approximately 3.4 mills in 2023. (The new rate will be finalized by Medina County in December.) That’s because more homeowners and businesses have moved into the district. With more taxpayers contributing, everyone’s share is reduced. Even when property values rise, the amount received by Cloverleaf remains the same because it is a fixed-dollar levy. Passage of the renewal – which accounts for 9.1 percent of Cloverleaf’s budget – is vital for the district to maintain its current level of service to students.

“It’s also important to note the State of Ohio pays 12.5 percent of this renewal,” said Treasurer Jim Hudson. “The state no longer offers this rollback on newly passed levies, but our taxpayers can continue to benefit by seeing these state tax dollars come back to Cloverleaf.”

In 2014, when the district emerged from Fiscal Emergency, the Board of Education promised not to ask voters for new funds until at least 2020. Not only is that promise on track to be extended to 2028 or beyond, the board will continue to look at making tax reduction part of its renewal requests going forward – something rarely, if ever, seen in Ohio, said Superintendent Dr. Daryl Kubilus.

On top of that, all Cloverleaf students soon will be in new or relatively new buildings – both completed without a taxpayer bond issue, thanks to Medina County sales tax funding for construction of Cloverleaf Elementary School in 2012 and tax revenue from the NEXUS natural gas pipeline for construction of a new 6-12-grade building, set to open in 2024.

“In the darkest days of Fiscal Emergency, our community rallied to support Cloverleaf,” Kubilus said. “We are more committed than ever to keeping faith with our constituents and to providing the best possible education for our students.”

How a "fixed-dollar" levy works

Daryl KubilusBy Daryl Kubilus
Superintendent
The word “emergency” typically means something is urgent or critical. That is why the term “emergency levy” is misleading. In fact, emergency levies have nothing to do with emergencies. A more accurate description of these levies is to view them as “fixed-dollar” levies. This means the amount generated by the levy stays the same year after year and the millage to produce that fixed-dollar amount is adjusted accordingly. On Nov. 8, Cloverleaf will be on the ballot to renew its 2013 emergency levy, which generates $2.8 million per year for a period of 10 years. This levy was first approved by Cloverleaf voters in 2005 and has been renewed since. Passage of this levy will not increase taxes.  Actually, fixed-dollar levies such as this one generally cost taxpayers less money over time.

Suppose 10 co-workers pooled their money to buy a colleague a $100 dinner gift certificate as a retirement gift. Each co-worker would contribute $10 toward the gift certificate (10 x 10 = 100).  Now, suppose instead of 10 workers participating, 12 co-workers contributed to the same $100 gift certificate. This would mean each coworker would contribute $8.33 instead of $10 ($8.33 x 12 = 100).

How does this relate to an emergency school levy? When additional residential or business properties are developed, more entities pay into the fixed-dollar amount of the levy, similar to more co-workers participating in the purchase of a retirement gift in the example above. The levy remains the same dollar amount today as it did in 2005, but any homes constructed or businesses developed since then are now contributing toward the fixed amount of the levy. In fact, this same emergency levy that generated the same $2.8 million in 2005 toward the district’s operating expenses cost taxpayers 6 mills at that time. Today, the same levy costs taxpayers 4.2 mills. The millage on this levy will likely decrease again over its life as new houses and businesses are developed and Medina County property reappraisals occur.

In the end, this $2.8 million per year levy accounts for 9.1% of our operating budget – a lower percentage than it did in 2005, but still a significant portion of our budget. In 2014, our district made a promise to taxpayers to not ask for new revenue until at least 2020. Renewing this levy enables us to continue to extend that promise well past our 2020 goal!

Voting Information

Election Day
The 2022 General Election is Nov. 8. Polls are open 6:30 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. Click HERE to find your polling place.

Voter Registration Deadline
The deadline to register to vote in the Nov. 8 General Election is Oct 11. Click HERE to register online.

Early Voting
Early in-person voting at the Medina County Board of Elections begins Oct. 12. Click HERE for dates and times.

Absentee Voting
Ballot requests must be received by noon on Nov. 5 and postmarked by Nov. 7. Request a ballot HERE.

Medina County Board of Elections
Office:
3800 Stonegate Drive
Suite C
Medina, OH 44256

Mailing Address:
P.O. Box 506
Medina, OH 44258

Office Hours:
8 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
(Monday to Friday)

Phone: 330-722-9278
Fax: 330-722-9299
Email: [email protected]

FAQs

Do you have questions about Cloverleaf's renewal levy on the Nov. 8 ballot? Please email them to [email protected]. Questions and answers of broad interest will be published here.

Sample Ballot

Sample ballot

For more

Please contact:
John Gladden
Community Information Coordinator
330-302-0311
View text-based website